NACA Community
Professors Create Fake Students to Spark Online Discussions

The Chronicle of Higher Education posted a story today about three professors who created fake student accounts for their online classes and used those "students" in online discussions. Two of the professors said the students had no idea that they had created fake online students, while the third professor told his students at the beginning of the class that he'd be posting in the discussions as a fake student.

The professors said that getting group discussions going is extremely difficult for online classes, and that many students tend to drop out of online classes mid-way through. But is this what higher education really wants? Do we want professors who pose as students mingling online with students? Some of the profs even admitted that they were close to the edge of faculty ethics and students in the story were not happy with the professors' actions.

What do you think? Is this just a clever way to get an online class discussion going or did these professors step over the line on this one?


Posted Thu, May 28 2009 2:19 PM by chrisn

Comments

Anon wrote re: Professors Create Fake Students to Spark Online Discussions
on Fri, May 29 2009 10:47 AM

That is crazy - there has to be a better way for professors to get discussion going.

Patti Wood wrote re: Professors Create Fake Students to Spark Online Discussions
on Thu, Jun 25 2009 2:08 PM

The professors in this case overstepped their professional boundaries and deceived the students in what is meant to be a safe, intellectually stimulating academic environment. Check out my blog (I'm a Body Language Expert) http://bodylanguagelady.blogspot.com to read about my research on deception detection.

Copyright NACA, 2006-2011. All rights reserved
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems